You’ve probably seen the news this week. The private keys for eight eMudhra intermediate CAs (six TLS, two code-signing) turned out to be trivially recoverable, and anyone can compute them from the public certs. Chrome, Firefox, Apple, Microsoft, and Android have all blocked them. But devices with a bundled CA store that don’t check revocation will keep trusting them until the certs expire, which is 2028 for the Sectigo cross-signs and 2040 for eMudhra’s own.
My concern is the IQ4’s cloud connection to Alarm.com. If the panel trusts a general-purpose CA bundle, an on-path attacker could present a forged cert for Alarm.com’s endpoints and the panel would accept it.
A few questions:
Does the IQ4 pin to a private or Alarm.com-specific CA, or does it trust a public root bundle?
If it uses a public bundle, does that bundle include emSign Root TLS CA - G3, emSign ECC Root CA - G3, or Sectigo’s AAA Certificate Services?
Does the panel check revocation (CRL/OCSP) and fail closed?
If it’s affected, is a firmware update planned from Qolsys or Alarm.com, and is there a rough timeline?
Same questions for the Alarm.com cellular communicator path, if it uses TLS separately.
Good question. I’d love to try to answer off the top of my head but let us dig in a bit and get confirmation from the manufacturers first. I’ll follow up shortly.
After discussing with JCI (IQ Security), I don’t think we’re going to get any information about the issue. If they find a vulnerability, they will disclose it here on the official security advisories page.
It would also be great if alarm.com documented/published RFO (reason for outage) reports/disclosures when they have an outage. I noticed when there is an outage they seem to just forget they ever happened, with no explanation. I’m surprised to see that in such a regulated and compliance oriented security industry focused on life safety. But my perspective is from other industries (Healthcare IT, FDA regulated systems, IT GRC, etc.) so maybe I’m being too harsh.
I’m not aware of a security disclosure or RFO page for Alarm.com. I’ll ask to be sure. I can assure you they don’t forget. But they’re not public about it.
If it helps, I heard that Alarm.com products don’t use eMudhra CAs. That’s not an official statement, just what I heard.